Sunday, January 18, 2009

Whose firstborn?

We could update the "photograph" of our congregations: true, they start before the birth of the coming babies or at their conception and include those whose might show in the future. And the Jewish specific feature is that Jewish women transmit Judaism as a mark of blessing in utero. In the Talmud, "Guf\גוף - body" is a fictitious sort of storehouse of soul in heaven, as in Tractate Yevamot 62a : "The son of David shall not come before all souls in the Guf\גוף are exhausted (sent to live on earth)" . This is interesting as regards the process of embodying each soul into a shape of flesh and blood - maybe some indication also found in relation with the "gilgul\גלגול - say: rolling soul" that may imply some migration of souls or reincarnation, though Judaism is very strict about personal carnal and mental destiny.

Each person is unique. At least, there is an undetermined number of potential souls that lead to the fulfillment of the Guf, thus not only a storehouse but the Divine Body in our world. Without being too E.T.-plugged and concerned about the existence of the galaxies, we, humans loitering on earth, do suffer of some "spiritual depressive symptom". In our 21st (58th) century, we know for sure that all possible tribes and nations were discovered on earth. Jews have the tremendous possibility to survey where the Lost Tribes settled and to find them eventually. But humankind may not reckon with the prospect that spiritual life and knowledge of God might exist as extensions of the Guf / Body still scattered in undefined galaxies or planets outside of the solar system.

This should be noted that Melekh HaOlam\מלך העולם – King of the Universe" is not our property, He reigns over the entire creation and entrusted the humans here, on earth, with special abilities to exist, develop or survive. But we might be willing in between to forget that the worlds are wide and on perpetual expansion.

Parshat Shemot\פרשת שמות (Exodus) reported the birth of Moshe and Eastern Christian Churches of the Holy Land celebrated the birth of Jesus. Firstborns are those, who have shown God's blessing of mother wombs, paralleled in the Jewish tradition with Pesach-פסח/Passover, i.e. the passing from slavery to freedom. Mothers might consider that they are indeed the true "slaves" as they domicile their children over nine months. And babies appear to be horribly "selfish" in their unconscious development or movements. On the other hand, "slavery" also implies lack of free space, absence of awareness. Slaves, as employees or executives, make their masters pretty much under their control. As regards babies, their passing through their mom's womb into the world creates a Pesach situation and somehow inaugurates the womb of a woman when she gives birth to her first son (Blog "call in utero" refers to male and female specifications beyond any sex competition).

The Semitic tradition relies upon an in-depth conscience that various sorts of sacrifices (zevachim) ensure a connection between God and the humans. Abraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov offered sacrifices. Progressively this was instituted in a structure that started with the firstborn sons, then the sons of Levi, and defined as "Kohen\כהן - priest". This means that a spiritual community cannot live without special functions. Thirty years ago, in Jerusalem and the Jewish society, there was still a low understanding that the " Beyt HaMikdash\בית המקדש - Third Temple" might one day be rebuilt and the Avodah restored in its midst.

Say that the Temple - without ordinal reference - is alive (qayam\קים - existing) right now on the Mount. Any really well-trained, Talmud-Scripture well-read and praying bar-mitzvah would immediately know how to function inside the Holy of the Holies because the "Avodah\עבודה - Service" has "only" been suspended - and certainly not destroyed or removed from the living Jewish memory and traditional teachings. The respect of the Commandments (Mitzvot) displays and bounces back such an in-life daily reality that governs social and family relationships.

In that respect, it is clear that every Jewish woman throughout history has impressively confronted the suspended Temple Service by birthing firstborns and well-educated men 'til the time of a restoration, if any. Their menstrual lunar cycle as their care of the "taharat mishpachah – family purity" endure until men might serve to the full. For instance, the whole ritual of Yom Kippur clearly describes how the priest Zorobabel reinitialized the Service, incl. the sacrifices in the Temple (Nehemiah, Ezra). The prayer of the 18 Benedictions (Amidah\עמידה) repeatedly insists on the performing of the sacrifices.

Some peopleget mad at the sight of some blood and can't stand the slaughtering of animals. But there is something anchored in the Jewish spiritual experience that calls each of us to pray (to make a "zevach todah\זבח תודה – thanksgiving sacrifice)". Why?

To begin with, the " call in utero" to serve God was reserved to the "bechor\בכור - firstborn son", i.e. a "reshit 'on\ראשית און – first fruit of (a man's) vigor, birthright is his due (lo mishpat habechora "(Devarim / Deut. 21:17)."Kohen\כהן" comes from the root "KaHaN\כהן" whose reflexive form is "nitkahen\נתכהן: be appointed, chosen as a priest for sacrifices"(Talmud Zevachim 101b). The root exists in all Semitic language and refers to "slaughter, make a sacrifice". The problem is that things seem to be systematic or that they developed by allowing certain priestly divisions. No. when the sons of Levi sinned, the priestly function was distributed in a new way. Rules are more flexible and a lot of Jews don't know how flexible they are. The provocative element is not the existence of priestly or "clerical" functions. The word "kohen\כהן" is originally connected with the root "KUN" which indicates a move, a continuous, coherent and dynamic move, thus as in "kavanah\כוונה = spiritual intention, intention to pray with fervor". The different roots or meanings of the root show that the real purpose is to develop a true way of living through the richness of the Jewish traditions, from the smallest to the highest step. But this cannot be a routine, procedure or a function. Jesus has an interesting statement: "let your 'Yes' (ken\כן) means 'Yes' and your 'No' (lo\לא) mean 'No'" (Matthew 5:37; cf James 5;12). Both Jesus and the apostle James declare that with regard to "oaths – nedarim" that are so essential in Jewish spiritual attitude.

The Eastern Orthodox Church of Jerusalem celebrates on January 13-14 the Circumcision of Jesus that also includes his been brought to the Temple and his "pedyon haben\פדיון הבן – redeeming of the (firstborn) son" (Luke 2:22-38). The account of the only evangelist who was a proselyte, shortly recapitulates with some lack of precision the different steps following the birth of a firstborn. Nonetheless, bikkurim\בכורים (firstborns) firstly belong to God as said: "Kadesh Li khol bechor\קדש לי כל בכור: consecrate to Me every first-born, the first issue of every womb among the Israelites is Mine (Exodus 13:2). Then: "You must redeem (tifdah\תפדה) every first-born among your sons" (Exodus 34:20) at a defined price: "Take as their redemption price, from the age of one month up, the money equivalent to five shekels" (Numbers 18:16).

We have a good example of such a situation with Hannah's son, Samuel the prophet, whom she had fervently asked to God and still she accepted that he should not be redeemed (1 Samuel 1:20). Thus he served in the Temple as a "regular first-born bechor\בכור".

At the present, there are different attitudes toward such mitzvot / commandment as the redeeming of a first born. There is certainly more: when the father accepts to redeem cash his firstborn, he takes upon himself the responsibility to retain in his own family circle a son of man who, by birth-call belongs to God and should be trained adequately. The family debits God from one server who is then able to live with the others.

There is something similar in the Gospel of Luke (2:22-38) that accounts the redeeming of Jesus as a firstborn. In that way, he is allowed to share his life with his family and does not only remain God's share. Interestingly, his baptism at the Jordan River by John the Forerunner will allow to follow up the meaning of the rites that fully exist in both Judaism and, at least, in the Christian Orthodox and Catholic Churches.

av aleksander [Winogradsky Frenkel]

January 16/3, 2009 – 20 deTevet 5769 - כ' דטבת תשס"ט

A call in utero



How can we define a "community"? Grownups assuming their mature adulthood, maybe later than some decades ago? Or some Banot/barey mitzvot-ברי\בנות מצות (respectively for girls and boys,12 and 13 years-old) could exercise their full capacities, religious duties, found a family and lead a congregation? It sounds a bit dreamy, but youths can sometimes raise their parents (Malachi 3:24: "to turn... the hearts of the children to their fathers"). A great number of newcomers are thus assisted if not taught the Israeli way of living by late teens who give them a click of Hebrew and a touch of administrative know-how. Still, it is difficult to consider them as self-sufficient or being totally responsible for themselves and others.

We are used to consider that a community is led by heads. Synagogues have rabbis, churches rely upon clergy. Both traditions refer to "semichah\סמיכה - ordination" - "chirotonia - laying of the hands" in Greek that is in force in most Christian traditions; with "new breaches" in some Jewish and Christian denominations which decided to ordain women (mainly Conservative, Reformed for the Jews and Episcopal / Protestant movements for the Christians).

But communities should not mirror some of their strong-minded heads! Let's say that we firstly envisage communities as a gathering of grownups, some of them having many young families and children, other more elderly people. A "kehilah\קהילה - community" reflects a wide spectrum that ranges from kindergarten to elderly home companionship. In some cases, people would not stand the presence of children or get nuts with them.Women? They have their space, not always so opaque to the others.

We rarely envision our community of faith and prayer as a living body mainly composed of former or future babies and, as a rule, as a process of birth. In Israel, there is no civil regulation of the legal wedding system to have babies in a secular way. Except if you go on a short journey to Cyprus or some other countries, some few embassies. But this has raised a lot of problems for the "chilonim\חילונים - seculars". Well, Jerusalem Teddy Kollek was openly an apikoros\אפיקורוס (sort of secular Jew with questions), a son of the former Habsburg Austrian-Hungarian Jewry. He was still a Jew, a character he received by birth.Thus it is normal that he was buried according to the Jewish tradition. Whether a prestigious Israeli personality or a simple citizen, "apikorosity or personal questioning" does not interfere for a community. It relies on a spiritual call that is difficult to deny in our society. There can be dramas: youths who arrived in the country as "olim chadashim\עולים חדשים" (newcomers), but still their Judaism was not "proven". For decades, some newcomers or new born babies were given an Identity Card (teudat Zehut\תעדת זהות) in which their "nation" was marked as "lo barur\לא ברור - not clear", "lo rashum\לא רשום - not registered". I even saw a "lo le'om\לא לאום - without nationality". At that time, there were many people under "bedikah\בדיקה - checking".

They were Israeli citizens or on the process to be recognized as such. I mainly speak now about how we cope with what is considered as "a birthright" – Israel is the State where any Jew may come, settle, be assisted to arrive, get full rights and duties before even having got to what the Israeli society presupposes today in its diversity. They are entitled to "return" to Israel because of their specific ties with Eretz Yisrael and the way the State can accept them as legally members of this community. This has been a challenging quiz over 2000 years. Then, to come back as "rapatrianty\рапатриянты - repatriates" as the former Soviets say is overwhelming because of a State of the Jews grounded on the Scripture. The unbelievable human family and personal backgrounds that makes this Israeli society unique is that it constantly refers to Jewish traditions and salient laws of flexible tolerance that deal with birth in peculiar contexts.

It is written: "God created man (et haadam\את האדם) in His Image (betzalmo\בצלמו), in the Image of God He created him; male and female ("zachar uneqavah\זכר והקבה") He created them"(Bereishit 1:27). But usual translations are wrong by definition. We could argue that this concerns one "adam" prototype composed of two vital elements, maleness and femaleness. This is linked to an incarnating process that fashions a body and substantiates the human developments. "Ki Atah qanita chliyoti\כי אתה קכליתי – You created/acquired my kidneys (conscience)" – Tesukeni bebeten immi\תסקני בבטן אמי – You fashioned me in my mother's womb" (Psalm 139:14). Then what about "zachar uneqavah\זכר ונקבה – male and female"? Good, "humankind" has "males and females". We live in a very unisex society (clothes, accessories, behaviors), sometimes on the verge of androgyny. Curiously the recent TV series dealing with the lives of hospital physicians, show more and more cases of "undetermined" sexual identity at birth. We might be either confused or driven toward some "abnormal defects".

There is this very ancient daily prayer that sounds firstly a bit special but is indeed very down-to-earth if not even hard-boiled: "Blessed are You, Lord of the Universe…/ Who fashioned man with wisdom (chochmah\חכמה) and many neqavim-נקבים/openings (mouth, nostrils) and chalulim-חלולים/cavities (stomach, brains) within him (Shacharit).As often in Semitic tongues, each word is repeated to underscore the importance of this human structure. "Zachar\זכר" (after the root seemingly underwent a change in the middle letter /ch/) means "to remember, recall". "Zechrut\זכרות" = male genitals (Talmud Sanhedrin 10:28d, Avodah Zara 44a), but also a "fructifying system, germ for plants, eggs" (Talmud Shabbat 7:9d). Memory and germinating factors mix up to produce life. Not only memory, but human decisions, brains, heart, feelings cause a man to look for a woman not only to "speak with" but to create a community", sort of joint-venture at times. "Neqavah\נקבה" determines "women as openings, orifices" as in "in the cavity (neqava\נקבא) wherein the pearl is seated" (Talmud Shabbat 90a).

There we have something that may often put aside in defining our communities. Man – as any animal or plant – but with the specification of making use of brains, will, conscience is the only creature to enjoy the same capacities as God to "fashion humans by birthing" and thus building families, tribes, communities that repeat what they were told: generations generate history open to the future of living bodies and souls. This is why the Halachah requires that every male give life by "clinging to his wife/woman – davaq bishto\דבק באשתו (Bereishit 2;24) – not the opposite. Males are the depositories of a seminal memory that allows to fashion, shape and create other human beings. This is an exceptional, totally sacred and natural capacity and, to begin with, the mark of a human identity. God said it was not good for him to be alone (Gen.2:18). Thus, Eve (Chavah\חוה) repairs this loneliness as "ezer kenegdo\עזר כנגדו – helper facing Adam" and flowing out God's imprints of male memory in shaping embryos, babies till they birth.

This is why men must observe the bound-to-time Mitzvot-מצות/Commandments while women are seemingly not time-bound (a few exceptions are mentioned in Talmud Qiddushin 33b). Women are naturally bound to time because of their machzor\מחזור (menstrual cycle and time of fecundity). Say that women are living throughout their life with the showing and disappearance of a fruitful physical and mental (thus also spiritual) calendar. This agenda basically corresponds, per days, to the lunar Jewish month.

We can then give whatever explanations about the fact that the character of being a Jew is transmitted by the mother. This is not stated in the Torah. It has a very special meaning: "You drew me from the womb, made me secure at my mother's breast. I became Your charge at birth; from my mother's womb, You are my God" (Psalm 22:10-11).

Being a Jew is a call in utero. Every human being is fashioned according to God's image and likeness. Before being delivered to this world, a Jew is already a child of Israel. On the other hand, no human being was born a Christian. Whatever origin, Christianity implies to be baptized. Interestingly, in case of emergency, every human – whatever backgrounds or beliefs – can perform a baptism. But no one was ever born a Christian. This is a problem for some nations that often consider they would have gotten some privileges because of their specific Christian backgrounds. Some Christian communities disappeared (North Africa, Arabia, Tibet, China, Mongolia).

On the other hand, sacredness has to be preserved and respected as the mark of God. This call in utero is unique and can somehow be compared to the Temple and the Shechinah (God's Presence). Indeed, the community of Israel starts before birth. Medical monitoring from the earliest days of conception allows at the present another positive attitude towards what a community is and our responsibility.

Quoting the Jewish tradition about the Shechinah\שכינה, Paul of Tarsus said: "Do you not know that you are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwells in you? If anyone destroys God's temple, God will destroy that person; for the temple of God, which you are, is holy". (1 Corinthians 3:16-17).

av aleksander [Winogradsky Frenkel]

January 16/3, 2009 – 20 deTevet 5769 - כ' דטבת תשס"ט

the fashioning of woman (Eve)
יצירת חוה

Who is where?

On Friday 16th of January 2009, we start reading a new Book as weekly portion, i.e. "Shemot\שמות - (the) Names" in Hebrew, called "Exodus or the flight from Egypt, the house of slavery" in usual translations and traditions.

In Hebrew, it is normal to refer to the first words of Biblical Book: "Ve'eleh shemot Bney Yisrael\ואלה שמות בני ישראל הבאים מצרימה את יעקב איש וביתו באו" = these are the names of the sons of Israel who came to Egypt with Jacob, each coming from his household" (Shemot/Exodus 1:1). We penetrate the history of a specific small Jewish rooted family. They entered Egypt out of hunger, were saved by Joseph, the son and brother they had left and sold, betrayed. In return, Joseph saved, nourished and redeemed them and made them honored by Pharaoh. Hebrew shows more: eleven brothers entered a foreign country that, at first glance, welcomed them and provided them with a lot of wealth in the fertile region of Goshen.

To begin with, the sons of Israel were accepted. There might have been other troubles or famines, as time passed. Then, a new Pharaoh showed up who did not know Joseph. The problem we have to face is that Jews are either too few, or too many -multiply or disappear by leaving a region. History has also shown how they were plundered, massacred. There is a point that should be highlighted. The Book of Shemot\שמות (Names) prolongs the history initiated in the Book of Bereishit (Commencement) -Genesis of all the universe, beginning with the creation of the world, planets, sun, moon, stars, vegetable and animal creatures and finally the humans. The Jewish tradition insists on that aspect. After thousands of years, Jews are trained to the fact that micro-groups of ten-twelve people can suddenly grow to millions after some centuries or eventually collapse in some circumstances

Jesus of Nazareth was born in Bethlehem into the humble family of a carpenter with a prestigious priestly and King David's backgrounds. He started with three Galilean disciples, then 12 that extended to 70 or 72 and finally there are millions of disciples. On the other hand, they did disappear, as the Jews, from some regions, often for the same reasons of rejection or collapse. This is why it is important to take into account this Book of Shemot because it obliges to humble ourselves: Shemot\שמות means "Names" and the Jewish people were conceived as in the image and likeness of God-Elohim (Gen. 1:27) (HaShem - the Only Name) and they only belong to This Name or aim to testify to this Holy Name. Jews have no other reason to exist than to engrave God's Presence into a without soul. This allows another connection to "Shem", Noah's son who is the ancestor of the Semites, dwelling in a place "there (sham\שם)" where The Name is present.

Then, Exodus, from Greek "going - way out", explains the development of a nation in a hostile context. They came to be blessed with food and wealth. They are forced into bondage and seem to be satisfied with their slavery when God decides to save them against their will. We can hardly figure out today what happened by the time of Moshe/Moses. This account is more than relevant, consequential and far-reaching: we trace back this week to the roots of a call to permanent freedom and perpetual release from bondage. There is some extravagance to being born in order to testify that the Lord constantly frees a special group as the model of leberation process proposed to all humankind. This process has been renewed over and over again throughout the ages. This implies other invariant patterns: how to relate with the pagans, the Gentiles. How to overcome our stiff mental reluctance to move ahead. The honest monotheistic believers admit that freedom is worthier than any tricky involuntary projects ordered by hating rulers.

There are some similarities between the birth of the Jewish boy Moshe, saved from killing all Israelite newborns and being adopted by the sister of Pharaoh (Shemot 2:5-11) and the birth of Jesus, the murder of all the Jewish babies ordered by Herod. He fakes to be willing to praise the newborn and wants to know where he was born in order to slay him (Matthew 2:1-12). Then, another Joseph (son of Jacob, (Matthew 1:16)) is told in a dream: "Rise, take the child and his mother, flee to Egypt." Thus, Herod became furious and ordered the slaughter of the boys in Bethlehem and its vicinity two years old and under, citing Prophet Jeremiah (31:15): "A voice was heard in Ramah, sobbing and loud lamentation; Rachel weeping for her children and she could not be consoled since they were no more." The Church recalls the "Children massacred by Herod" soon after the Nativity of Jesus. When Herod died as a tyrant, Joseph "took the child and his mother and went to the Land of Israel (Eretz Yisrael\ארץ ישראל), but fearing Herod's son, they settled in Nazareth (Matthew 2:21-23).

There is a fathomable similarity between the two accounts: to fathom consists to measure "with outstretched arms" as God always did and does. Exodus 6:6 (or Deuteronomy 4:34) is cited in almost every single Jewish prayer: "bizro'a nituyah\בזרוע נתויה = with outstretched arm (I will redeem you)".

In both cases – commemorated at the same time, with parallel and dissimilar views – Jews and Christians firstly recall the birth and saving of Moshe and, on the other hand, the birth and saving of Jesus. In both cases the will to power is so resolute, violent and mighty that murders are preferred to life. Of course, it was totally bizarre to the enslaved Jews to be protected by the man they considered as the son of Pharaoh. Again, we face "appearance" vs. "being" as when Joseph appeared to his brothers as an Egyptian manager. Our generation never experienced the singularity reported in the reading of this week. We survived thousands of years of pagan hatred and two millennia of estranged bewilderment in our facing other monotheistic communities. Jews settled too often in various parts of the world with the impression that – remaining somehow or totally faithful to the Jewish traditions – they would be protected by some sort of rulers. This is a tragic bluff that deceived generations. In the Shemot reading, we see how Moses is conscious of being a foreigner (his first son is Gershom\גרשום = (I) was a stranger there). Is it the chronicle of a liberation process? We might be tempted to make comparisons, all through history. Exodus is and remains unique as it climaxes with Pesach\פסח / Passover and the going-out from bondage to delivery.

There might be more. Humans are good at reducing God to a sort of despotic ruler Who issued numerous ordinances, some of which we comply with; and most often we systematically select those we accept or reject. This is the dialogue between God and Moses at the bush that does not burn up "has'neh bo'er ba'esh vehas'neh eynenu ukal\והסנה בער באש והסנה איננו אכל" (there was a bush all aflame, yet the bush was not consumed – Ex. 3:2). God said to Moshe: "I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob". The root of the word "S'neh\סנה – thorn bush" is connected to Aramaic/Hebrew (different spelling): "sina\שנאה – hatred, removal".

God is different, totally alien to any sort of image we can figure out. Humans use to hide themselves or try to be high-profile in this world. Such a bush changes any moment into times of eternity and any jealousy into wiping out wickedness. This is what Rabbi Yehiel Michal of Zlotshov explained when he said that Abraham had accomplished all the 613 Mitzvot\תרי"ג מצות / Commandments. He declared that Abraham loved God with all his heart, soul and spirit. Moshe progressively gets to this point: being "dressed" as a foreigner to his own people. God is indeed loving and kind, faithful and merciful. He turns and returns to the human beings constantly, with much faithfulness to a call.

From the time of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob until Joseph and the 12 sons of Israel, Jews have been alien (they do not enjoy the same rights as the local citizens) even if Machpelah is theirs as the "the burial site bought by Abraham from Ephron the Hittite" (Gen. 50:13). There are tons of small or bigger nations that hate each other for racial, cultural, social, economic reasons. In this particular weekly reading, we have to face the kernel reason: Jews only exist to attest that, from nil, God calls to being; He calls to enhancement, unexpected growth and freedom. Eretz Yisrael is given to the twelve sons of Israel as a permanent lease for life. Thus, Judaism is bringing forth non-perishable seeds of reality, survival and hopeful continuance.

Two texts from the Talmud are very similar: Tractates Nedarim 39b and Pessahim 54a.They explain that before God created heaven and earth, seven counselors were discussing with Him to know whether it made sense or not to launch the process! These pre-existing advisors were: Torah\תורה, Teshuvah\תשובה (penance), Kisse HaKavod\כסא הכבוד (Throne of Glory), Devir\דביר (Holy of Holies), Gan Eden\גן עדן, Gey Hinnom\גיי הינום (Gehenna) and Shem HaMashiach\שם המשיח (Name of the Messiah).

They appeared step by step, through the process of historical development. But one thing is constant, endures and questions us at the present. Even back in Eretz Yisrael, how do we prove to be seeds of freedom? Moses was thus given a password to speak to the enslaved Jews: God has a Name: "Ehyeh Asher Ehyehאהיה אשר אהיה" (Shemot 3;14).This Name continues to convulse and reshuffle our daily lives and paths. Say it may correspond to "I am Who I am" – frankly, it sounds stiff; correct, but inelastic and aloof. God is merciful... The burning bush without consuming reveals that God's Name means: "I will (not 'shall') be/come the Who to the fullest of Who I will be/come". This sounds jet-set stylish, but read again, please: it is a motion without automatics; or "I will become/develop to exist to the fullest the One (Who)I will live to the full".

With Exodus, we face a new creation project as read each Shabbat: "Vaychulu hashamayim vehaaretz\ויכולו השמים והארץ – heaven and earth were achieved" (Gen. 1:31). Not finished: "yachulu\יכולו" echoes an action on the move to the full, as the kallah\כלה (bride) who begins her life-long path with her special one.

Someway, Jesus summarized what God proposes to any Jew and believer: "Foxes have dens and birds of the sky have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to rest his head" (Matthew 8:20).Indeed, we start, this week, a huge trip with the go-getting Name of the Lord!

In these days of hardships and confusion, it maybe terrible for all the nations and the people embattled in the conflict in the Middle-East and Israel, Palestinian Territories under control of the Palestinian Authority, to clear our minds. Whose shemot/שמות-names? What kind of Exodus? From where to where and for whom with whom; for the sake of whom or what? There are indeed times and delays.

The Shabbat and the One Church as One Body is like Jesus' tunic: it is not a lot, a gambling party, it is impossible for any human to tear it up. There are days and nights when we appear to be lost. God searches unity and leads us though to discernment.

Av Aleksandr [winogradsky frenkel]

January 11, 2009/Dec. 29, 2008 – 15 deTevet 5769 - ט"ו דטבת תשס"ט


Jerusalem by night - ירושלים בלילה
The sign of Resurrection - Anastasis, Jerusalem.

The Monk Anthony The Great

The Monk Anthony The Great (356 AD)
By Reader Michael Hann

a very great ascetic, the founder of wilderness-monastery life and as such the father of monasticism, is entitled "the Great" by Holy Church. He was born in Egypt in the village of Coma, near the Thebaid wilderness, in the year 251. His parents were pious Christians of illustrious lineage. From his youth Anthony was always serious and given over to concentration. He loved to visit church services and he hearkened to the Holy Scripture with such deep attention, that he remembered what he heard all his entire life. The commandments of the Lord guided him from the time of his very youth. When Saint Anthony was about twenty years old, he lost his parents, but in his care remained his sister, a minor in age. Visiting the church services, the youth was pierced through by a reverent feeling towards those Christians who, as it relates in the Acts of the Apostles, sold off their possessions and the proceeds thereof they applied in following after the Apostles. He heard in church the Gospel passage of Christ, spoken to the rich young man: "If thou wouldst be perfect, sell what thou hast and give it to the poor; and thou wilt have treasure in heaven; and come follow after Me" (Mt. 19: 21). Anthony understood this as spoken to him personally. He sold off his property that remained to him after the death of his parents, he distributed the money to the poor, he left is sister in the care of pious virgins in a monastic setting, he left his parental home, and having settled not far from his village in a wretched hut, he began his ascetic life. He earned his livelihood by working with his hands, and alms also for the poor. Sometimes the holy youth also visited other ascetics living in the surrounding areas, and from each he sought to receive direction and benefit. And to a particular one of these ascetics he turned for guidance in the spiritual life.

In this period of his life the Monk Anthony was subjected to terrible temptations by the devil. The enemy of the race of man troubled the young ascetic with thoughts, and with doubts about his chosen path, with anguish over his sister, and he attempted to incline Anthony towards fleshly sin. But the monk preserved his firm faith, he incessantly made prayer and intensified his efforts. Anthony prayed that the Lord would point out to him the path of salvation. And he was granted a vision. The ascetic beheld a man, who by turns alternately finished a prayer, and then began to work -- this was an Angel, which the Lord had sent to instruct His chosen one. The monk thereupon set up a strict schedule for his life. He partook of food only once in the entire day, and sometimes only once every second or third day; he spent all night at prayer, giving himself over to a short sleep only on the third or fourth night after unbroken vigil. But the devil would not desist with his tricks, and trying to scare the monk, he appeared under the guise of monstrous phantoms. The saint however with steadfast faith protected himself with the Life-Creating Cross. Finally the enemy appeared to him in the guise of a frightful looking black lad, and hypocritically declaring himself beaten, he reckoned to sway the saint into vanity and pride. But the monk expelled the enemy with prayer.

For yet greater solitude, the saint re-settled farther away from the village, in a graveyard. On designated days his friend brought him a scant bit of food. And here the devils, pouncing upon the saint with the intent to kill him, inflicted upon him terrible beatings. But the Lord would not allow the death of Anthony. The friend of the saint, on schedule taking him his food, saw him as though dead laying upon the ground, and he took him away back to the village. They thought the saint was dead and began to prepare for his burial. But the monk in the deep of night regained consciousness and besought his friend to take him back to the graveyard. The staunchness of Saint Anthony was greater than the wile of the enemy. Taking the form of ferocious beasts, the devils again tried to force the saint to forsake the place chosen by him, but he again expelled them by the power of the Life-Creating Cross. The Lord strengthened the power of His saint: in the heat of the struggle with the dark powers the monk saw coming down to him from the sky a luminous ray of light, and he cried out: "Where hast Thou been, O Merciful Jesus?.. Why hast Thou not healed my wounds at the very start?" The Lord replied: "Anthony! I was here, but did wait, wanting to see thine valour; and now after this, since thou hast firmly withstood the struggle, I shalt always aid thee and glorify thee throughout all the world". After this vision the Monk Anthony was healed of his wounds and ready for renewed efforts. He was then 35 years of age.

Having gained spiritual experience in the struggle with the devil, the Monk Anthony pondered going into the deeps of the Thebaid wilderness, and in full solitude there to serve the Lord by deed and by prayer. He besought the ascetic elder (to whom he had turned at the beginning of his monastic journey) to go off together with him into the wilderness, but the elder, while blessing him in the then as yet unheard of exploit of being suchlike an hermit, decided against accompanying him because of the infirmity of age. The Monk Anthony went off into the wilderness alone. The devil tried to stop him, throwing in front of the monk precious gems and stones, but the saint paid them no attention and passed them on by. Having reached a certain hilly spot, the monk caught sight of an abandoned enclosed structure and he settled within it, securing the entrance with stones. His faithful friend brought him bread twice a year, and water he had inside the enclosure. In complete silence the monk partook of the food brought him. The Monk Anthony dwelt for 20 years in complete isolation and incessant struggle with the devils, and he finally found tranquillity of spirit and peace in his mind. When it became appropriate, the Lord revealed to people about His great ascetic. The saint had to instruct many layfolk and monastics. The people gathering at the enclosure of the monk removed the stones sealing his entrance way, and they went to Saint Anthony and besought him to take them under his guidance. Soon the heights on which Saint Anthony asceticised was encircled by a whole belt of monastic communities, and the monk fondly directed their inhabitants, teaching about the spiritual life to everyone who came into the wilderness to be saved. He taught first of all the need to take up spiritual efforts, to unremittingly strive to please the Lord, to have a willing and unselfish attitude towards types of work shunned earlier. He urged them not to be afraid of demonic assaults and to repel the enemy by the power of the Life-Creating Cross of the Lord.

In the year 311 the Church was beset by a trial -- a fierce persecution against Christians, set in motion by the emperor Maximian. Wanting to suffer together with the holy martyrs, the Monk Anthony left the wilderness and arrived in Alexandria. He openly rendered aid to the imprisoned martyrs, he was present at the trial and interrogations, but the torturers would not even bother with him! It pleased the Lord to preserve him for the benefit of Christians. With the close of the persecution, the monk returned to the wilderness and continued his exploits. The Lord bestowed upon His saint a gift of wonderworking: the monk cast out devils and healed the sick by the power of his prayer. The multitude of people coming to him disrupted his solitude, and the monk went off still farther, into the so-called "interiour of the wilderness", and he settled atop an high elevation. But the brethren of the wilderness monasteries searched out the monk and besought him at least often to pay visits to their communities.

Another time the Monk Anthony left the wilderness and arrived amidst the Christians in Alexandria, to defend the Orthodox faith against the Manichaean and Arian heresies. Knowing that the name of the Monk Anthony was venerated by all the Church, the Arians circulated a lie about him -- that he allegedly adhered to their heretical teaching. But actually being present in Alexandria, the Monk Anthony in front of everyone and in the presence of the bishop openly denounced Arianism. During the time of his brief stay at Alexandria he converted to Christ a great multitude of pagans. Pagan philosophers came to the monk, wanting by their speculations to test his firm faith, but by his simple and convincing words he reduced them to silence. The Equal-to-the-Apostles emperor Constantine the Great (+ 337, Comm. 21 May) and his sons deeply esteemed the Monk Anthony and besought him to visit them at the capital, but the monk did not want to forsake his wilderness brethren. In reply to the letter, he urged the emperor not to be overcome with pride by his lofty position, but rather to remember, that even over him was the Impartial Judge -- the Lord God.

The Monk Anthony spent 85 years of his life in the solitary wilderness. Shortly before his death, the monk told the brethren, that soon he would be taken from them. Time and again he instructed them to preserve the Orthodox faith in its purity, to shun any association with heretics, and not to weaken in their monastic efforts. "Strive the yet more to dwell ever in unity amongst ye, and most of all with the Lord, and then with the saints, so that upon death they should bring ye into eternity by their blood, as friends and acquaintances", -- thus were the death-bed words of the monk passed on in his Vita (Life). The monk bid two of his disciples, who had been together with him the final 15 years of his life, to bury him in the wilderness and not arrange any solemn burial of his remains in Alexandria. Of his two monastic mantles, the monk left one to Sainted Athanasias of Alexandria (Comm. 18 January), the other to Sainted Serapion of Tmunta. The Monk Anthony died peacefully in the year 356, at age 105, and he was buried by his disciples at a treasured spot glorified by him in the wilderness.

The Vita (Life) of the famed ascetic the Monk Anthony the Great was written in detail by a father of the Church, Saint Athanasias of Alexandria. This work of Saint Athanasias is the first memorial of Orthodox hagiography, and is considered one of the finest of his writings; Saint John Chrysostom says, that this Vita should be read by every Christian. "These narratives be significantly small in comparison with the virtues of Anthony, -- writes Saint Athanasias, -- but from them ye can conclude, what the man of God Anthony was like. From his youth into his mature years observing an equal zeal for asceticism, not being seduced by the avenues of filth, and not as regards infirmity of body altering his garb, nor the any worse for it in suffering arm. His eyes were healthy and unfailing and he saw well. Not one tooth fell out for him, and they only weakened at the gums from the advanced years of age. He was healthy of hand and of foot (...). And what they said about him everywhere, all being amazed at him, whereof even those that did not see him loved him -- this serves as evidence of his virtue and love for God in soul".

Of the works of the Monk Anthony himself, there have come down to us: 1) his Discourses, 20 in number, treating of the virtues, primarily monastic, 2) Seven Letters to monasteries -- about striving for moral perfection and regarding the spiritual struggle, and 3) a Rule of life and consolation for monastics.

In the year 544 the relics of the Monk Anthony the great were transferred from the wilderness to Alexandria, and later on with the conquest of Egypt by the Saracens in the VII Century, they were transferred to Constantinople. The holy relics were transferred from Constantinople in the X-XI Centuries to a diocese outside Vienna, and in the XV Century -- to Arles (in France), into the church of Saint Julian.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Prayer of imagination

Prayer of the imagination, of the mind, of the heart
by Rd. Michael Hann

As we pass from without to within, we first encounter the powers of imagination and fantasy. ' Many people stop here, not realizing that they must immediately pass beyond this first stage: for if we work chiefly through our imagination and fantasy, we are not yet praying in the correct way. This, then, is the first incorrect method of prayer. The second stage on the way within is represented by the reason, intellect, and mind, and in general by the rational and thinking power of the soul. Nor must we linger here, but pass on: and gathering this rational power together, we must descend into the heart. If we linger, we shall become involved in a second incorrect method of prayer, whose characteristic feature is that the mind remains in the head, wishing by itself to direct and govern everything in the soul. Nothing comes of these efforts: the mind pursues everything, but cannot dominate anything, and only undergoes defeats. This feebleness from which our mind suffers is described very fully by St. Simeon the New Theologian.2 This second way of prayer can appropriately be termed 'mind-in-the-head', in contrast to the third way, which is lmind-in-the-heart'. At this second stage, while this mental fermentation takes place in the head, the heart goes its own way; nobody watches over it, and so it is invaded by cares and passions, and only with great difficulty comes to itself again.

To this account of the second way of prayer, I would add a few words from the introduction to the writings of Gregory of Sinai,3 written by the staretz Basils monk of the great habit,1 companion and friend of Paissy Velichkovsky.2 Having quoted Simeon the New Theologian, staretz Basil adds: 'How can you hope to keep the mind intact merely by guarding your exterior sensations, when your thoughts by themselves stream in different directions and whirl towards material things ? It is essential for the mind, in the hour of prayer, to withdraw as quickly as possible into the heart and to stand there, deaf and mute to all thoughts. Whoever withdraws only outwardly from seeing, hearing, and speaking, obtains little result. Enclose your mind in the inner cell of the heart, and then you will enjoy rest from evil thoughts; and you will experience the spiritual joy which is brought by inner prayer and attention of the heart.'

St. Hesychios3 says: 'Our mind cannot defeat evil dreams by itself alone; and let it never hope to do so. Take heed, therefore, not to think highly of yourself like the old Israel, lest you also be delivered up to our invisible enemies. When the God of all creation delivered Israel from the Egyptians, the Israelites fashioned a molten image to be their helper. By the molten image you should understand our feeble mind: when it invokes Jesus Christ against the spirits of wickedness, it drives them away easily; but when in its folly it trusts wholly to itself, it experiences a sudden and grievous downfall.'

-St Theophan the Recluse

1 On the meaning of 'imagination' here, see above, p. 2 c.
2 St. Simeon the New Theologian (949 1022), Abbot of the Monastery of St. Mamas in Constantinople: probably the greatest of Byzantine mystical writers.
3 St. Gregory of Sinai (late 13th cent. 1346), monk on Mount Athos, one of the leaders of the Hesychast Movement.
4 Staretz Basil (died 1767), a Russian by birth, Igumen of several monasteries in Romania. He wrote introductions to the works of various Greek authors who discuss the Jesus Prayer

1 Orthodox monks are divided into three grades: rasophore (one who wears the rason or cassock), monk of the little habit, and monk of the great habit (or schema monk). Only a few monks enter the third and highest of these grades, the great habit: in Russia a schema monk is normally expected to follow a life of strict seclusion and fasting (in Greek monasteries the rules for schema monks are often less rigorous).
* Paissy Velichkovsky (1722-94), Russian by origin, entered the monastic life on Mount Athos and later settled in Rumania, where he became Igumen of the monastery of Niamets. Editor of the Slavonic edition of the Philokaha. The spiritual and monastic renaissance in 19th century Russia was in large measure inspired by his disciples and followers.
3 St. Hesychios of Batos was superior of a monastery on the Sinai peninsula during the 6th or 7th century.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

What kind of living?


The Jewish world consists of a continuous and steady blessing process, from getting awaken in the morning to washing the hands, putting on the great prayer shawl, donning the tefillin [phylacteries] and a series of daily repeated actions: eating, learning, working and praying.

We move ahead in life under the guidance of "uttered words\מאמרות - m'amrot". They emphasize how sacred, beautiful and new it is to be alive and enjoy the marvels of our environment, the nature, humans, animals... We bless our homes, cats, friends, wives or husbands or betrothed; we say (or at least should say) blessings upon our cups of tea, peanut cream, wine, water or mitz\מיץ (fruit juice), when seeing a rainbow, a scholar, a person we have not seen for one year. The problem is to avoid getting like automatons.

Or to bless anything that only relates to ourselves. Some spend their day scorning the others. They love taking a sort of selfish breath. There is a very close link in Judaism between blessings and curses. And we are quicker to judge people and curse them than to curse ourselves, G-d forbid! The problem of this systematic recognition that holiness is everywhere in the world may be tiresome.

It may be boring to handle perpetual blessings that ring up like bells (some would only try on a trip to Israel). It is definitely not evident to bless, true! And to accept that these words work indeed. They do heal and cure, they repair individuals, communities, nations and why not? yes blessings - i.e. words uttered in the name and spirit of the Creator - can do it and be a great remedy. Now, please, think it over! how do we behave when we socialize or when we refuse to meet with others? : this neighbor, co-worker, politician, actor, doctor, we ought to bless them!?

And simply this cracked-up auntie who could give a loan on a free basis; she is just a mess as we - her family - and some of her friends agreed at some anti-defamation meeting last week. Well, we all turned to "lashon hara'ah\לשון הרעה - vicious gossiping, venomous speech", but it was so refreshing! This is maybe worse than any defects: to say wrong, malicious and killing words against anybody in our thoughts while uttering holy blessings. Indeed, sometimes we desperately need enemies. There are special moments though: for example when people die. An energizing flash of peaceful meditation and possible care. Last wills can be intriguing.

In this weekly reading portion “Vayechi\ויחי - (and Jacob) lived”, Israel [Jacob] is about to die. He calls his son Joseph, meets with Menashe and Ephraim and, seemingly dim, blessed Ephraim (junior) instead of Menashe (senior) with his right hand.

By accomplishing this peculiar gesture, he foresaw a greater and more fruitful descent. It is important that their grandfather confirmed their adoption in the Tribes. Thus, whatever link existed through Dinah, Joseph's sons were not Jewish by their mother. Nonetheless, each Shabbat, a family father blesses his children in recalling their names. Israel asked Joseph to bury him in the Land of Canaan. Then he called each of his sons and blessed them with very relevant phrases and statements about their characters and specific future for each tribe. It should be noted how he blessed “Simon and Levi (who) are a pair (achim); their weapons are tools of lawlessness…let not my person be included in their council… cursed be their anger so fierce… I will divide them in Jacob, scatter them in Israel” (Gen./Bereishit 49:5-7).

This sounds a bit rude. Jacob-Israel is quietly ending his life abroad but with his family and a prophetic future that shall be accomplished by his sons. The patriarch (third “av\אב = father) ends his days with decency, after a life of labor and cheat. He grew old as a man and became mature in the face of God. Isaac would not have blessed Yaakov and Esau the way Israel blessed his sons. The twins were then competitors bogged down in lentil soup, birthright and blessing capture with a mom’s push; this does not show the same grandeur as leaving the world without any lady’s care, honored by Pharaoh (70 days of wailing decreed in Egypt after Yisrael’s death).

Still he departs in exile, envisioning his gathering with Abraham at Machpelah cave. Yaakov has a remarkable demand to Joseph in such circumstances: “Place your hand under my thigh as a pledge of your steadfast loyalty (chesed ve’emet\חסד ואמת)” (Gen. 47:29). Both a paternal symbolism and a recall of his injury forever as Israel. Joseph will receive Simon and Levi’s portions but he must witness for the fragility of unexpected divine assistance.

The problem of Jewishness is that Abraham's children being are called to bless all the peoples, without exception. They are called to teach and show evidence that blessing is a real activity and a set of manifold sources to living good things. Who can do it and accept that "blessing" is a "living", a human, economical, historical and spiritual free birthright without any privilege or presupposed return or repayment? blessings? Is this a living? Blessing cannot be disguised or fake. Bilaam experienced this and his cursing turned into a blessing of Israel. His tongue twisted because of the intervening of his she-donkey. He was a pagan soothsayer; his words are uttered by all the Jews that start to read the morning prayer after the putting on of the tefillin: "How goodly are your tents, Jacob, your dwelling places, Israel\מה טבוו אהליך יעקב. משיכנתיך ישראל (BeMidbar 24:5). Even if they might be disguised in brilliant dressings or sketch out foxy know-hows.

“Blessaðu” is still normal in Icelandic to say “Hello” in a polite way. “God bless” is Christian and interfaith Anglo. The word is related to “blood” (Old Germanic: “Blothisojan = to sprinkle blood on the altars”). The Anglo-Saxon word got sweeter by a mistake when specialists thought the root was the same as for “to bliss” which is lovely. Indeed, “bless” corresponds to the meaning of sacrifices (korbanot\קורבנות), the blood of lambs at Pessah (and Christian Easter), as the “Aid al Adha” (Muslim Feast of the Sacrifice) in which so many sheep and lambs were slaughtered in a way that tracks back to Abraham and Isaac’s binding to the Prophet: “like a sheep being led to slaughter, like an ewe dumb before those who shear her” (Isaiah 53:7;cf. Preparation of the Gifts in the Byzantine Orthodox tradition).

In Hebrew, the usual word is “brachah\ברכה”(blessing) and “barech\ברך” (to bless). It is basically connected with “beri – bara\ברי-ברא” (to create) that initially consists “to perforate” – “think out a plan”. “When the Lord wanted to create man (adam\אדם), He first created (thought out) all the means of his support and then created Adam (Talmud Sanhedrin 38b – Gen. Rabba 8).

It should be noted that, indeed, Adam is a “bar\בר” (son) of the same root as “to create”. Thus, a blessing consists in “sorts of perforations", holes, apertures allowing to instill strength, growth, refreshing, new creation. God proposes to screw us up although we don’t feel hurt nor see any holes! To begin with, the words of blessing renew and achieve something of what we got since we exist and live in a defined environment.

A sort of spiritual, legal piercing! The “Laying of the hands” is thus important in the Jewish tradition in a kind of “sacrificial offering” that changes the life of the blessed: the hands were exerting a pressure upon the head (semichah\סמיכה; samech\סמך = stamp, perforate). “Samech”, the name of the fifteenth letter /s/ means “punch” as the thin knife used by the shochet\שוחט (kosher slaughterer) to speedily kill the animal that must die immediately and be kosher. Blessings imply a change from death to life. Interestingly, the weekly reading is called “Vayechi” (And Jacob lived) because his death and repose at Machpelah introduce a new move of fertility and growth linking generations by means of blessings.

Then, “barekh\ברך” means “to cave out, select, choose, point out”: “HaQadosh Baruch Hu\הקדוש ברוך הוא” (The Holy One, Blessed He be) as in Talmud Pessahim 118a, Who, in turn, praises and blesses His creation, not the contrary. “hivrikh\הבריך” develops the action: “to form a knee, to graft a plant, wine” as “two good shoots (proselytes) have been engrafted to Ruth” (Talmud Bava Kamma 38b; cf. Epistle to the Romans 11:13 about the Gentiles engrafted to share the roots of the olive tree without boasting).

Moreover, a blessing implies the growth of “birkai\ברכי” (shoots, branches) who will be satisfied with waters. As it is regular in the Semitic tongues, positive and negative aspects can alternate in paradoxal ways according to the context: “barekh\ברך” can also mean “to blaspheme”: “…Until he blasphemes the Lord by His name” (Talmud Sanhedrin 56a). This is a very profound and sensitive experience that blessing and cursing are closely tied, as love and hatred, praising and scorning, mocking.

This is a very specific call to bless people and be a mark of blessings. In the case of Israel, it is a “congregational, community, international” service of God. This is the core meaning of Israel’s destiny because blessing intrudes that we take over the sufferings and the joys of the nations. This call cannot be superseded or seized by mental or physical "raping actions of capture". On hte other hand, the monotheistic believers have a part in the same call to blessing, as shown in Bilaam's prophecy.

Blessings comply with the order of the words as in the verse: “Bo’u\באו (come), nishtachaweh\נשתחוה (bow down til earth), venikhra’ah\ונכרעה (kneel down) venivrachah\ונברכה (bend the kneels to be blessed) lifney HaShem ossenu\לפני ה' עשענו (in the face of God Who makes us)” (Psalm 95:6, said before reading the Psalms in the Jewish and some Christian traditions). This move is special because it induces yeridah\ירידה (falling, getting to nil) and then olah\עולה (raising) with the blessing. In the Scroll of Esther, Mordechai refused to kneel and bow down before Haman (Esther 3:2-5). This movement is reversed compared to the psalm.

The three Wise Men who came to visit Jesus in Bethlehem acted according to the correct order of the verse, i.e. giving thanks to God for the new born child (Matthew 2:11). As we read this portion, the Oriental Churches have celebrated the Nativity of Jesus on January 6-7 in Bethlehem, the city of David. The King's depose is also read this week as Haftarah (Additional prophetic reading) in the Jewish tradition (1 Kings 2:1-12).

“Yechi!\ויחי” ! The weekly reading recounts the death of Yaakov-Israel in exile. “Yechi\יחי” = may he live” is similar to Batshevah’s cry: “yechi adoni David le’olam va’ed – may my Master David live forever\יחי אדני דויד לעולם ועד” (Kings 1:1-31).

King David is also considered as a messianic character as reminded in the prayer (New Month/Moon): "David, king of Israel is living and enduring\דוד מלך ישראל חי וקים ". He had abandoned Bethlehem, built, combated and killed his enemies or competitors. On the other hand, Yaakov-Israel could be murdered several times. The same prophetic call to universal blessing echoes from Bethlehem, as David is “Messiah” in the Jewish tradition and “yechi\יחי – may live or he lived” incites to bless our society with the mark of goodness and hope in these days of terrible hardships.

It seems that burying the ancestors is a major activity in the first book of the Scripture. Funerals and burials constitute a constant concern in this first account that deals with the history or destiny of all humankind. It is a constant quest and interrogation: Adam and Eve left the Gan Eden where there was an empty tomb guarded by the Cherubim. Cain hid from the face of God after he had killed his brother Abel. Jealousy showed already in archaic times with the same spirit of competition as today: who is best, first, beloved by God. Why should my sacrifice be better than ours or yours?

Thus, Abraham bought a cave and buried Sarah. Isaac and Rebekkah joined them in the same land. Being abroad, Jacob and Joseph also desired to rest with their fathers. This means that their burial was reversed into a source for the living. This is something that hardly can be understood at the present.

We are facing a huge, tremendous, immense, tantamount challenge. This is simply mentally unbelievable: who can accept that the return to Zion cannot be reduced to a political or philosophical quarrel and contest. We are in a unique situation: who could ever think that Joacob would be buried with Abraham at Machpelah? It is the same area as Efrata-/Efrat and Bethlehem.The same challenge as for David and Jesus whose name means "[Yah] saved, saves and will save". Who can really comprehend that the question is that God entrusted by oath of a permanent renting [not possession] a Land to Abraham and his seed/descending [Romans 9:4-6]. The cave where they were buried is a source of life. This is defies reason, it is more than any challenge. It explains that we may have to wait for years, decades, centuries before the living graft of humans can be recognized. We are embattled in recognizing that God chooses life and sustains it.

Av Aleksandr [winogradsky frenkel]

January 10/Dec. 29, 2007 – 15 deTevet 5769 - י"ט דטבת תשס"ט
dried grape trees in Jerusalem
Ein Karem Orthodox church of St. John the Baptist

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Sanctifying life


The problem with "emunah\אמונה" (faith, confidence) is that we cannot easily get convinced that light and trust enlighten darkness. This requires "trust": we often were deceived, then Understanding: who understands us and are we in-depth committed to understand someone, others, close or foreign, ourselves? Creeds and beliefs would often turn to repeat stiff-necked or obstinate secure dogmas. Job's peacefully stated after his horrible test: "Indeed, I spoke without understanding of things beyond me, which I did not know. Hear now and I will speak; I will ask and You will inform me. I had heard you with my ears, but I see You with my eyes..." (Job 42:3-4).

This year, Tuesday 6th of January, 2009, corresponds to the 10th of Tevet 5769\י' דטבת תשב"ט. It is the day when "in the ninth year of his reign, on the tenth day of the tenth month, Nebuchadnezzar moved against Jerusalem with his whole army. He besieged it, and they built towers against it all round" (II King. 25:1). Prophet Ezekiel carefully recorded the "exact day - et-etzem hayom hazeh\את עצם היום הזה (Ezekiel 24:2) which marks the beginning of the Churban/destruction of the First Temple. Asarah beTevet\עשרה בטבת (Tevet 10th) is thus a fast day. The Chief Rabbinate of Israel has also decided that it is the Yom HaKaddish HaKlali\קדיש הכללי - General Kaddish memorial day for all those who perished on unknown dates during the Shoah-Churban/Chirb'n\שואה-חורבן. This underscores a strong link between the Temple and us as living divine dwellings, made of sinews, muscles, bones, limbs, brains (cf. Prophet Ezekiel 37). It means that we shall leave 2008 after a mourning day for those who perished, because, whatever personal moral attitudes, they had the mark of God's blessing to witness that love (life) is fierce(r) as (than) death - ki 'azah khamavet ahavah\כי עזה כמות אהבה (Song 8:6).

The Kaddish is one of the most ancient prayers said by the Jews. It tracks back to the exile in Babylon. This Aramaic word means "holy" and the whole text is in this language, except the famous "osseh shalom bimromav\עושה שלום במרומיו - He Who makes peace in the High, may also make peace upon us and upon All Israel and say Amen" (with variants), which is in Hebrew and sung upon landing in Israel or other conventions. The point is that there are five different texts of the Kaddish to be said on various occasions. The Prayer is in Aramaic, the then colloquial tongue and understood by everybody, both Jews and non-Jews, which was important for the proclamation of God's Reign that embraces every creature. Although the "Kaddish yatom\קדיש יתום - orphan's (mourner's) Kaddish" is the most famous text, none of the Kaddish variations focus on death. They exclusively refer to life, God as life-Giver, His Name, Kingdom, Reign over the creation. Many Jews who lived in remote places have often kept with much respect the transliteration in Russian, Latin, Arabic, Greek, Chinese script of the text that they would recite without understanding the meaning of the words. They would even be very surprised to discover it is an utmost strength-empowering prayer for more blessings. In Yiddish, Kaddishele\קדישעלע is the one who is chosen to say the prayer for some people without descent.

True, nobody confessing the God of the Living is alone or left without "blessed memory - zichrono/a livrachah\זכרונו-ה לברכה" ("vechnaia pamiat'\вечная память - eternal memory" in the Byzantine Churches, with lists of names read at some Services). It is evident that, at the Yad VaShem Memorial Center, the constant recall of the 1.500.000 children whose names are pronounced in Hebrew, Yiddish and English insists on humans killed in their early age.

To begin with, the prayer was uttered after learning a portion of the Torah or the Talmud or a sermon delivered by rabbis. Rabbinical Kaddish\קדיש דרבנן (deRabbanan) continues to be a major blessing after learning. The rabbis teach God's Scriptures to disciples who embody the community. Upon Israel and her rabbis and their disciples (students), and upon all those busy in the Torah, here and in every other site, that they and you have peace, grace and kindness, mercy and long life, and abundant nourishment, salvation from their Father (Avuhon\אבוהון דבשמיא) Who is in heaven and say: Amen.

Faith proceeds from a community that accepts to be taught and thus turns to God and His teachers from generation to generation. This is fundamentally a dynamic action.

The Orphan's (or mourners') Kaddish Yatom\קדיש יתום was seemingly adopted rather lately 13th c.). It shows how it firmly imprints us with life and does not refer at all to death. It is recited everyday during the thirty days of mourning, and the yohrzeit\יארצייט - anniversary of death. It must be pronounced slowly and with much respect. Burial Kaddish\קדיש דאתחדתא (de'itchadata) focuses on the world-to-come, the rebuild of Jerusalem and the Temple, opening an era of ulma'qar pulchana nuchra\ולמעקר פולחנא נוכרא - the erasure of foreign (pagan) worship from the earth and the renewal of the Service to the Holy One.

The very kernel of the Kaddish always starts with the wonderful words based on Prophet Ezekiel 38:23: "Itgaddal veyitqaddash\יתגדל ויתקדש... Exalted and sanctified be the Great Name (of God) in the world that He created according to His Will and may His Kingdom reign (be established), may His salvation blossom and His anointed come near (not Ashkenazi text), in your lifetime and in the days of All the House of Israel, speedily and soon and say: Amen."

Full Kaddish\קדיש שלם (Shalem) inserts: "Titqabel na tzlot'hon\תתקבל נא צלותהון... May the supplications and prayers of All Israel be received by her Father Who art in heaven (Avuhun divshamaya, also in Aramaic)". This lines word for word with Jesus' prayer as he taught his disciples how to call upon the heavenly Father: "Our Father Who art in heaven (Avun divshmaya) - hallowed be Your Name (yitqadash Shmekha) -may Your Kingdom come - Your Will be done (khirute\כרעותא)" (cf. Matthew 6:9-14).

As the civilian calendar shifts, it is maybe good that it corresponds to the General Kaddish memorial day and the fast of Tevet 10th. We are imperiled with terrible and lasting wars, immoral breaches, cultural and spiritual downfalls. The world is submitted to violence, misery.

Unexpectedly, the Kaddish comprehends those who, as so many of our citizens, were Jews for a very small part of their identity and though sentenced to death, a lot of Christians, Gypsies, people entrapped by error or miserable informers, gays and lesbians, Slavs and communists, disabled and mentally sick. Kaddish does not look back into the past... On the contrary, it envisions how the living may produce life and enjoy it without harming it.

Indeed the Kaddish includes the words that let us climb up from earthly humans to their heaven Father and backwards as a ladder or even an escalator... in our days, speedily and soon.

The Qaddish is very-very ancient and tracks back to the first memorized prayers uttered in history. It was also pronounced in Sumer, i.e. present-day Iraq where daily massacres are perpetrated against all human beings. There was the cradle of monotheism.

When we pray in Israel and Palestine, we ought not forget the murders that daily affect our human brothers and sisters in Iraq.

And we never forget that the Lord is magnified and hallowed and exalted in the world that HE has created ACCORDING TO HIS WILL.

av aleksandr [Winogradsky Frenkel]

January 5, 2009 - December 23, 2008 - 9 deTevet 5769 - ט,דטבת תשס"ט
We need a cock, a rooster to tell us when it is night and when it is daytime; to remind us not to cheat or betray, but trust and love,
birth and call to pray together to the Almerciful.